You are here:   History > Underrated: Martin Gilbert


The Rt Hon Sir Martin Gilbert CBE is the official biographer of Winston Churchill, author of more than 80 books and collections of maps, Honorary Fellow of Merton College, Oxford, Honorary Fellow of Churchill College, Cambridge, member of the Chilcot Inquiry into the Iraq war, laureate of the $1 million Dan David prize for 2012, historian chosen to accompany both John Major and Gordon Brown on official visits to the Middle East. 

Underrated? Unfortunately, very much so in academe. Far from being sources of respect among university-based historians, his many honours seem only to intensify the disdain and neglect of his work by lesser scholars. As he lies impeded after a stroke, it is time to express gratitude for an immensely important life's work which will have a lasting impact when the books, articles and conference papers of journeymen professors are forgotten. 

When he was a research fellow at Merton, his former tutor A.J.P. Taylor advised him to apply for lectureships at a number of universities. Fearing the fate of the anti-hero of Kingsley Amis's Lucky Jim, and already well-known for his pioneering studies of appeasement in the 1930s, he determined to make his way as an independent, full-time researcher and writer. In 1968, Randolph Churchill, Winston Churchill's son and official biographer, suddenly died. As a younger colleague at Merton, I remember the day Gilbert prepared a suitcase of writings and documents to take to his interview with the former premier's trustees. He was soon the new official biographer. An architect designed a home on Hinksey Hill, The Map House, to accommodate the many feet of desk space he required to set out Churchill's documents. 

The Churchill connection brought the young Gilbert close to leading statesmen and also to Israeli affairs. In the Six-Day War of 1967, Randolph Churchill had telephoned Moshe Dayan to give strategic advice. Gilbert assisted with Randolph's subsequent study of the Israeli victory. By 1973, he had another close link with the establishment of the Jewish state. His second wife was the daughter of Michael Sacher, of the family which founded Marks & Spencer and which had been among the main backers of Israel's first president, Chaim Weizmann. The trust he enjoyed was demonstrated when Yigael Yadin, the archaeologist and Israeli general, took Gilbert into Israel's command centre during the crisis of Egypt's surprise attack which started the Yom Kippur War.

View Full Article
Patrick Dempsey
October 23rd, 2015
6:10 PM
As an author on The Holocaust, it has been an essential part of my research to look toward those like Arad, Bauer, Gutman, Dawidowich and Gilbert to understand, appreciate and accept the complexities of the Catastrophe. Each would be qualified to exemplify what research is required to even approach comprehension, though those who Survived, I would adjudge, have more of an impact as impassioned as any who witnessed what we cannot yet come to terms with!

Robert T. Boyter
July 25th, 2014
8:07 PM
The Left isn't prejudiced against Professor Gilbert, it is prejudiced against the subject of his lengthy biography. Despiet Churchill's sympathy for Jewish causes and Jewish people, the Left persist in viewing him as a product of 19th Century Tory-ism. I suspect if you canvassed academic opinion, you'd find that Gilbert's work on appeasement and the Holocaust would both be held in high esteem. That the Left, to whom I belong, are so short sighted as to allow blind prejudice to outweigh the herculean effort on the Churchill biography is an example of a sort of decadence setting in among the Politically Correct minority who sadly make more heat and noise than light and sense.

Roger Dulson
July 13th, 2013
1:07 PM
THE Historian of Historians. The Historian with an open mind. Respect you Sir Martin, be as well as possible.

March 15th, 2013
7:03 PM
sir martin worked in the churchill vineyard for 40 plus years going through tons of documents who will take over now .

Dr George Abbott White
February 26th, 2013
5:02 PM
Only the "left wing"? Seems to me - in USA - there is more than enough anti-Semitism to go around all the wings, including the Right. At least as important an element in academic non-recognition strikes me as the fact that Gilbert has completed a number of significant projects that have reached a very wide, non specialized readership. Like David McCullough in the USA, damning enough by itself.

January 22nd, 2013
4:01 PM
@Brian Wimborne: My thoughts exactly.

Brian Wimborne
December 19th, 2012
11:12 PM
It is not surprising that the works of a Jewish historian are ignored by today's academia where leftist historians predominate. Anti-Semitism has been a pillar of left wing ideology since the nineteenth.

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.