You are here:   Civilisation >  Theatre > Train Crash and Mother's Ruin

Fiona Shaw as Mother Courage at the National 

The shadows of the Second World War seem to lengthen ever more quickly and 70 years have passed since Hitler invaded Poland. Coinciding with last month's anniversary were two major new London productions of plays written almost exactly at that time by two young Germans in exile, reflecting on evil at home and the possibility of war. Bertolt Brecht wrote Mother Courage and her Children in 1939 in Sweden and Ödön von Horváth wrote Judgment Day in Vienna in 1936/7. Both were writing in direct response to the forces gathering in Nazi Germany, and both address — or certainly intended to address — much wider concerns about the human predicament, of which their view was understandably bleak. 

None of this makes for a nice night out at the theatre. But then again, that is precisely what Brecht thought we bourgeois oppressors should not have anyway. However, the unBrechtian theatregoer might be inclined to wonder whether there is really much point in subjecting oneself to an evening or two of misery. In the 70 years since Brecht and Horváth wrote these plays, such an immense wealth of drama, cinema, documentary and literature has been laid before us, in so many attempts to understand the horrors of the 20th century, that it sometimes feels as though we have had too much of investigating these shadows. Very few bloodstained stones remain unturned and perhaps these distant voices are losing their power, especially when, as with Brecht, the voice is above all else didactic: didacticism tends not to last.

Brecht, after all, is discredited politically, and though he is a good poet and his songs with Kurt Weill make The Threepenny Opera a great masterpiece, many of his plays are boring and bad. Mother Courage is certainly far too long. 

Horváth is little known in this country. Even so, anything that interests the writer Christopher Hampton — he has created a sharp new translation of Judgment Day for this production at the Almeida (until 17 October) — is worth seeing. So, too, when the National Theatre decides to put large amounts of money and its best talent into a big production, such as this hugely ambitious and pyrotechnical Mother Courage at the Olivier (until 8 December), it seems a pity to miss it, just out of a reaction against the Brechtian orthodoxies. Fiona Shaw as Courage, Deborah Warner directing, Tom Pye as set designer, a new translation by Tony Kushner and new music from a strange sounding musician-performer called Duke Special are too tempting to ignore.

In my youth, when Brecht was achingly fashionable and his dramaturgical diktat almost holy writ among young British thespians, one approached any production with some trepidation about getting it — it being the Brechtian McGuffin, or rather the whole range of them, from "alienation" through "gestus" to "epic". How old-fashioned that all sounds now. What seemed so edgy and subversively politically "relevant" back then, in the first post-war decades, has been so thoroughly ingested and digested, and then either excreted or incorporated by theatrical convention, that it is imperceptible to new audiences. It's true that most productions today owe something to the influence of Brecht and Brechtians, but it is also true that little of what he demanded of theatre was really new at all, as he admitted himself. Shakespeare did alienation too, regularly breaking the theatrical illusion with asides to the audience from various characters, with lines aimed to please the groundlings and so on.

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.