You are here:   Features > The Operation That Can Ruin Your Life
 

 
A photographic exhibition at the Hammer Museum, University of California Los Angeles, shows a comparative study between teenage girls and adult male-to-female transsexuals 

Last year, I was nominated for the Stonewall Journalist of the Year award. This seemed fair enough since I write prolifically about sexuality and sexual identity. But I guessed that Stonewall would not dare give me the prize, because a powerful lobby affiliated with the lesbian and gay communities had been hounding me for five years. Six weeks later I, along with a police escort, walked past a huge demonstration of transsexuals and their supporters, shouting "Bindel the Bigot". Despite campaigning against gender discrimination, rape, child abuse and domestic violence for 30 years, I have been labelled a bigot because of a column I wrote in 2004 that questioned whether a sex change would make someone a woman or simply a man without a penis. Subsequently, I was "no platformed" by the National Union of Students Women's Campaign, a privilege previously afforded to fascist groups such as the BNP. As a leading feminist writer, I now find that a number of organisations are too frightened to ask me to speak at public events for fear of protests by transsexual lobbyists. 

The 2004 column was about a Canadian male-to-female transsexual who had taken a rape crisis centre to court over its decision not to invite her to be a counsellor for rape victims. Feminists tend to be critical of traditional gender roles because they benefit men and oppress women. Transsexualism, by its nature, promotes the idea that it is "natural" for boys to play with guns and girls to play with Barbie dolls. The idea that gender roles are biologically determined rather than socially constructed is the antithesis of feminism. 

I wrote: "Those who ‘transition' seem to become stereotypical in their appearance — f**k-me shoes and birds' nest hair for the boys; beards, muscles and tattoos for the girls. Think about a world inhabited just by transsexuals. It would look like the set of Grease."

Gender dysphoria (GD) was invented in the 1950s by reactionary male psychiatrists in an era when men were men and women were doormats. It is a term used to describe someone who feels strongly that they should belong to the opposite sex and that they were born in the wrong body. GD has no proven genetic or physiological basis. 

A review for the Guardian in 2005 of more than 100 international medical studies of post-operative transsexuals by the University of Birmingham's Aggressive Research Intelligence Facility found no robust scientific evidence that gender reassignment surgery was clinically effective. It warned that the results of many gender reassignment studies were unsound because researchers lost track of more than half of the participants. 

The past decade has seen an increase in the number of people diagnosed as transsexual. There are now 1,500-1,600 new referrals a year to one of the handful of gender identity clinics in Britain. About 1,200 receive treatment on the NHS with the rest going private, Thailand being the main country of choice. The largest clinic, at Charing Cross Hospital in London, saw 780 new referrals last year. The NHS carried out some 150 operations in the last year (up from about  100 in 2005-2006). Apart from Thailand, the country with the highest number of sex-change operations is Iran where, homosexuality is illegal and punishable by death. When sex-change surgery is performed on gay men, they become, in the eyes of the gender defenders, heterosexual women. Transsexual surgery becomes modern-day aversion therapy for gays and lesbians. 

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Laura
February 5th, 2010
2:02 PM
While I don't agree with most of Bindel's core beliefs that post op transpeople have less validity in others perceptions of their identities and that it validates selective discrimination, and I feel much of her language is violent and insulting, I do find the aggression against her from the trans community extremely disturbing. It reminds me far too much of male pattern aggression and personally I find that challenges my perception of transwomen as essentially female on the grounds of their brains. As somebody with many M2F friends I find this challenging and difficult to understand and accept and sadly it only validates Bindel's incorrect belief that GID is the output of social prejudice against sexual and gender atypical behaviour.

Nicole H
February 4th, 2010
3:02 PM
While I disagree with most of this article, I think Ms. Bindel makes some valid points. There are some people who rush into Gender Reassignment surgery and later regret it. From my experience, those cases are rare. I was 54 y.o. before having my surgery and spent 15 years coming to that decision. Transitioning is a long, hard, and expensive process. 90% of people never complete transitioning due to the difficulties. Some Trans people replicate gender stereotypes because they long to fit into "normal", which in our current society is a binary gender concept. Younger Trans people are more experimental and blurring stereotypes with Gender Queer identities. Trans people are evolving just as the Gay and Lesbian culture is.

Keltik
February 3rd, 2010
12:02 AM
Oh wow, another bigot in the LGBT community! What a surprise! Better watch out the trannys don't get you!

Barb
February 2nd, 2010
3:02 PM
What hypocrisy! The author reduces the gender identity of transgender people to questions of their biology, while hiding behind the right of women not to be defined solely by theirs. I also am astonished by her useless quoting of statistics about increasing access tto services for transgender people as if that justifies her position. Does the increasing access to marriage for same-sex couples prove that homosexuality doesn't exist? Does increasing numbers of women in executive positions prove they belong at home in the kitchen? Those make about as much sense!

T.C.
February 2nd, 2010
9:02 AM
Ms Bindel, I have heard quite alot about you but had never read any of your work. Now that I have I have some critiques of your articles. I am trans FTM and as other people have stated. I battled with my gender identity for years before I decided to do anything about it. I was deeply unhappy living as female, it just never felt natural to me. When I learned about the existence of transexuality I knew exactly what I had to do. I have battled for months with doctors and phychologists to be refered for HRT (hormone replacement therapy) you see ms bindel it's not all about the "sex change surgery" one's transition is a long hard journey to become the person you have always felt you are. To be trans is not a choice but it is a choice to do something about it.just like coming out as gay in some ways. You speak of trans people in the same way people spoke of LGB people 30-40 years ago. You need to inform yourself on the issues that trans people face and the transition process, but also you need to learn about the reasons that people transition. Furthermore, you need to abandon this notion that people transition to become heterosexual. Not all trans people are lesbian or gay before they transition. I for one am bisexual but I am currently in a gay relationship with a male partner and I am A MAN! Gender and sexuality have absolutly nothing to do with eachother. Before critisising trans people for what they are doing you need to think about what you would feel if someone wrote very insulting articles about you being a lesbian, if somebody repeated insulting steriotypes and called you a dyke and said that you want to be a man because you shag women, and so on, you would feel as though you have been attacked for who you are, for living how you feel comfortable. That is what you are doing to us. This is why you have received such animosity from the community you have deeply insulted trans people for their very right to live their lives freely. I think one of the reasons that trans people are so defensive other than your outragious transphopic comments and articles, is because we have nobody to defend us. Transphobia is accepted alot of the time, we havn't the resources afforded to LGB people even though we need the support just as much if not more sometimes than LGB people. So as soon as somebody attacks us as you have and re-enforeces the misconceptions and biggotry again as you have. It sets back all our hard work for rights and visibility. To be frank you perpetuate the oppression of trans people. I've said my piece and the majority of people, I think you will find, will side with me rather than an ignorent transphobe

Alexandra
February 1st, 2010
6:02 PM
Wow there's so much wrong with this but I don't even know where to begin with someone who thinks that gender stereotypes only ever benefit men and never women. It's quite obvious from this article why Julie waw no-platformed.

Anonymous
January 29th, 2010
11:01 PM
I absolutely agree with Julie Bindel. A vagina is not merely something you can stick a penis into, and having a pair of silicone breasts and wearing dresses doesn't make you a woman. Pro-'sex change' people congratulating themselves on how radical they're being would do well to reflect where their support base lies - 'sex change' operations are legal in Iran, while homosexuality is not. Accepting your biological sex while pursuing whatever body shape, relationships and wardrobe you want is far more ground-breaking and socially challenging than adopting binary ideas of gender (which is why I do have respect for people who are genuinely seeking to blur gender rather than reduce it to a set of signifiers). As for the idea that someone can be 'born into the wrong body' - this bizarre quasi-mystical belief stems from an outmoded, deeply conservative mind/body duality. You ARE your body. I have no problem with people choosing to dress, fuck and act how they like, and while I find cosmetic surgery repulsive, if people want to risk their health for the sake of their appearance, it's their call. But I'm sick of the reactionary idea that being a woman can be reduced to appearance and social demeanour.

Anonymous
January 26th, 2010
9:01 AM
I like how the second page of this story read off a definition of transgender as an umbrella term and then the writer immediately switched to trans-sexual in their next paragraph as if they were interchangeable. Clearly, this person knows very little about trans-sexuals and especially transgender if it's assumed that binaries aren't being enforced by those with privelege.

Redstar Chimera
January 24th, 2010
11:01 PM
A lot of you are missing the point when you accuse Julie Bindel of being ignorant, some helpful souls have even pointed her towards "trans-101" type resources. She's not ignorant. The long and the short is that she needs something to write about, bigoted rants are the easiest articles to write that an author can then actually sell, and transsexuals are still considered to be a legitimate target for this kind of thing. Trust me, if she was capable of earning a decent living putting out honest, balanced articles then we would not be having this conversation.

Anonymous
January 10th, 2010
9:01 PM
I really dislike this post. There is something physical about transsexuality. Your body does not feel right and you want it to be different. I cannot fathom how you could have a problem with that. How on earth does it effect you? What right do you have to say that these people are just gay. That is so insulting. There are plenty of extremely feminine gay men, and they are not transsexuals. Transsexuals want to have the body of a woman (or man, as the case may be). I am really upset now.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.