You are here:   China > Moscow's Middle Ground


President Barack Obama's engagement strategy with Iran has run aground. His numerous entreaties to the Supreme Leader were publicly and privately rebuffed. His lukewarm reaction to Iranians as they demonstrated against their rulers and suffered repression did not win him new friends in Tehran — and may have lost America its most precious allies in Iran.

Obama's resolve to bestow legitimacy on the clerical regime was met with the appointment as minister of defence of the mastermind of the 1994 bombing of a Jewish cultural centre in Buenos Aires. Stopping federally-funded programmes to promote human rights in Iran or document the regime's human rights abuses have failed to persuade Iran's leaders of a new dawn in bilateral relations. And the much-publicised nuclear deal with Iran has unravelled.

Whether such failures will now lead the administration to reconsider its approach to Tehran is an open question. However, the chances for a significant change depend on discarding a number of deeply held beliefs. None is stronger than the belief that a successful diplomatic effort depends on concerted multilateral action, which includes Russia and China.

Over the years, both Europe and the US have consistently pursued this strategy. Multilateralism yielded some results. In December 2006 and March 2007, the UN Security Council unanimously introduced sanctions against Iran, through resolutions 1737 and 1747. But this approach soon ran into trouble. It took an additional year to get more sanctions adopted — and the new resolution 1803 added only a few names to an already less than satisfactory list. Since then, nothing more than a reaffirmation of these sanctions has made it through the UNSC.

Russia is responsible for much of the stalling — with China hiding behind Moscow. Much of Obama's strategy was presented as an attempt to ensure that the Kremlin co-operated. Indeed, no price seemed too high-scrapping missile defence in Central Europe was just the latest in a list of gifts the White House gave Moscow as an inducement.

There is no doubt that turning Russia around to support sanctions against Iran would be a great achievement, one that would obviate at least some of the drawbacks of delays and watered-down sanctions. And if Washington were to announce that engagement did not work, the alternatives would be more effective if Russia went along rather than obstructing. But can Russia be turned around?  

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.