You are here:   Columns >  Manchester Square > An Archbishop Spinning out of Control
 

 

Three years ago, Standpoint was founded to defend and celebrate Western civilisation. In this summer double issue, some of the best writers, artists and thinkers in the English-speaking world demonstrate that our civilisation is by no means in decline. Yet its ideas and values are constantly distorted, ignored or betrayed by those whose duty is to sustain them. 

I want to examine a figure who has, by virtue of his office, his officiousness and his obfuscation, turned himself into the very model of that modern major generalist: the public intellectual. Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury, should not be underestimated. He is the 104th Primate of All England, and one of the most prolific. If Dr Williams is more often to be seen (and seems more at home) in the secular realm — praising Philip Pullman at a literary festival, say, or condemning the killing of bin Laden — than when speaking ex cathedra to the fractious Anglican Communion, that is not accidental: he wants to be seen playing in the intellectual premier division, not relegated to the Sunday charity match. Of course, the day job often pays dividends: public intellectuals may pontificate on royal weddings, funerals and coronations, but only Primates preside over them. 

This summer, while moonlighting as guest editor of the New Statesman, Dr Williams did what he does best: provoke a political controversy. Such rows have become a regular occurrence since his translation from Wales to Canterbury in 2003. But the usual explanation — the presumptive political ineptitude of an unworldly divine — seems to me implausible, though even the sapient Charles Moore subscribes to it: "No holy spin doctors seem to be charged with the exacting task of explaining what this brilliant but mentally bearded man actually means." On the contrary: Dr Williams is his own spin doctor, and a very successful one too. His name is rarely absent from the news for long; his ubiquity is matched by his hyperactivity. The fact that his whiskers and his mannerisms are endlessly caricatured and mimicked is proof positive that his voice is heard in the land. "Rowan" (as he is known by admirers among clergy and laity alike) is the Church of England's first celebrity archbishop — almost as famous as the Vicar of Dibley. Some see him as a prophetic, persecuted voice. He has got off lightly compared to some of his predecessors: Becket, Cranmer and Laud were respectively martyred, burnt and beheaded.

But what does this sibilant sibyl actually have to say? Does the Primate earn his primacy? He argues that the present Conservative-Liberal coalition lacks democratic legitimacy: "With remarkable speed, we are being committed to radical, long-term policies for which no one voted. At the very least, there is an understandable anxiety about what democracy means in such a context." It would be charitable to suppose that Dr Williams was unaware that the Coalition received 59 per cent of the votes cast at the 2010 general election, making it the only government since 1945 to achieve an absolute majority of the popular vote. But representative democracy has been familiar since 5th-century Athens. Has the Archbishop never heard the term "vox pop", which derives from the medieval saying Vox populi, vox Dei — "the voice of people is the voice of God"?

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Anonymous
July 15th, 2011
3:07 AM
Dr. Williams disregard for the urgency of the Anglican split demonstrates that he is out of touch with reality. He should never have been appointed AB. I hope his successor has greater wisdom and gumption to speak out against well meaning, but spiritually unfaithful theological revisionists in the Anglican Church.

Chrysostom
June 30th, 2011
10:06 AM
Last year, the Pope was in Britain and spoke as one with authority on important matters. Ronan shows what happens when people adopt political correctness instead of the truths of Christ. The Pope will not compromise on women priests, homosexuality, abortion, artificial contraception and all the other moral items taught by the Catholic Faith for 2000 years. Mind you, the English Catholic bishops seem closer to Rowan than the Pope.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.