You are here:   Faith > Britain Can Benefit from Benedict

On May 13, 2004, a septuagenarian German intellectual gave a lecture in the Capital Room of the Italian Senate. Ironies — or at least paradoxes — abounded. 

The lecturer was a Catholic priest and bishop; the modern Italian state had been born in a decades-long spasm of anti-clericalism. The lecturer, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, was known throughout the world as the living embodiment of Catholic orthodoxy. The man who had invited him to speak, Senate president Marcello Pera, was a non-believer and a philosopher of science in the school of Karl Popper. Cardinal Ratzinger chose as his topic, "The Spiritual Roots of Europe: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow". As he spoke, Europe was nearing the end of a fierce, year-long debate over whether biblical religion had had anything to do with what was noble in Europe's past, or might have something important to say about Europe's present or future. 

As Joseph Ratzinger, the man who became Pope Benedict XVI, comes to Great Britain on a state visit on September 16 that will include the beatification of John Henry Newman, his lecture in the Italian Senate some six years ago is well worth revisiting. It serves as a reminder that seemingly endless stories of clerical sexual abuse and the mismanagement of these sins and crimes by Catholic bishops are not the only story to be told about the Church at the end of the first decade of the 21st century. Important as the airing of the abuse story has been in compelling the Church to address grave problems that had long been buried beneath the carapace of a self-protective clerical culture, the press's obsession with clerical sexual malfeasance has also been a distraction — doubtless welcome in some quarters — from grappling with important arguments the present Pope and his predecessor have made about the ideas shaping democratic societies today, arguments that invite serious men and women to think seriously about the democratic future. And if the sanguinary 20th century ought to have taught the West anything, it was the truth of Keynes's famous observation that "ideas...both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else." 

The man who comes to Britain as the 264th successor of St Peter is many things. Britons who rely on media imagery to form their impressions of public personalities will find some of those things surprising. Those who expect to meet "God's Rottweiler" (as his theological enemies caricatured Cardinal Ratzinger decades ago) will find instead a shy, soft-spoken man of exquisite manners. Those determined to portray Pope Benedict as the central figure in a global criminal conspiracy of child-rapers and their abettors will, it may be hoped, discover the man who did more than anyone else in the Roman Curia to compel the Church to face what he once called the "filth" marring the priesthood. Those looking for a hidebound clerical enforcer will meet instead a man of deep faith, a gentle pastor who has met, wept with, and apologised to the abused victims of his brother priests and bishops. 

Voices of reason: Benedict XVI —then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger — and his predecessor as Pope, John Paul II 

Joseph Ratzinger is also a man of ideas: a world-class European intellectual with an intriguing analysis of contemporary Europe's present circumstances and bold proposals to make about Europe's future. During the Pope's visit to Britain, those who ignore those proposals because of their fixation on scandal are depriving themselves of an opportunity to think seriously about the moral and cultural condition of the West — and indulging that intellectual anorexia at a moment when the West's future seems anything but secure demographically, economically, fiscally, strategically or morally. 

View Full Article
September 23rd, 2010
1:09 PM
An excellent article. Just one small quibble: Iona and Lindisfarne were occupied by Celtic, not Benedictine, monks.

September 18th, 2010
9:09 AM
An excellent article. Re Fabio's comment- quite. I have stopped reading British newspapers. Their hate-filled intolerance, in the name of what Benedict calls pathological relativism, make me ashamed to live here. But there is cause for optimism. I think Catholics have felt empowered and strengthened by this visit, myself included.

September 6th, 2010
4:09 PM
Qui bono regsrding the Pope's visit? The hate, mouth-foaming, and religious hostility is not small-minded anti-Papism from militant Protestants like it used to be. It's more much an expression of the hostility felt to the active criminal conspiracy by the Church's leaders to bury recognised criminal acts. In avoiding the issue, hiding behind spiritual humbug and unctuous pronouncements, and playing the victimisation card, a huge amount of the Church's moral authority has been lost, and it will take more than just harking back to conservative Catholic mores to put it right.

Fabio P.Barbieri
September 2nd, 2010
4:09 PM
I wish I were so optimistic. The Pope should never have accepted that invitation - from Gordon Brown, of all raging enemies of Christianity! - and if he had, he should have rescinded his acceptance after the Foreign Office scandal. This country has been encouraged for the last few years to hate to an extent not seen since the Gordon Riots, and we can expect trouble when he appears. Incidentally, I predict that a majority of any letters on this thread will be hate-ridden, foaming-at-the-mouth displays of religious hatred. I have some experience of the mood of the British newspaper reader, and currently it is ugly.

August 29th, 2010
12:08 PM
A very fine article by Weigel. Thank you!

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.