You are here:   EU > Max Hastings, the Repentant Europhile

First man standing: Max Hastings, complete with camouflage paint and helmet, arrives in Port Stanley during the Falklands crisis in 1982 (PA)

Max Hastings is becoming something of a moral example to British national journalists and popular historians, and as his former employer, I am beaming proudly. It is not for me to minimise either the grace of conversion or the purgative value of confession. But with Max's recent announcement in the Daily Mail of his lapsed and renounced faith in Europe, like Stephen Daedalus's confession, there still need to "ooze out, sluggish and filthy" a few more self-reflections.

It is not true, as Max claims, that he "deplored Brussels' follies as much as anyone". He treated his colleagues at the Daily Telegraph newspapers who were Eurosceptic as "lunatics". He scoffed at concerns about excessive dirigisme, because, he endlessly repeated as if in a trance, "Europe is a good thing", and he was convinced that any British dismissal would make his frequent holidays in Italy more complicated. He conducted a ferocious intramural defence of Maastricht 20 years ago and leader conferences on the subject were re-enactments of the first day of the Somme.

He needed almost daily restraint from undercutting Margaret Thatcher, and was, I believe, the original source for the political insight that John Major tucked his shirt inside his underpants. (By my reckoning, next to Lady Thatcher, who should be universally recognised for her prescience and courage over Europe, John Major now seems, in policy terms, Britain's best peacetime prime minister since Salisbury, and a good war premier too.) After he left us, Max became an unpaid booster of the Labour Party. 

Max is a great natural journalist and was a strong leader of the editorial department. All who loved the Daily Telegraph owe him much. But we paid a price for his simplistic views, whim of iron, and ten-second attention span. He came back from five days in South Africa all for effectively throwing the whites out of the country, and from two days in Ulster championing a "troops out" approach. His first book, after he briefly lived in the United States in the Sixties, predicted the complete and imminent self-immolation of that country. He had some pretty arbitrary views on the Middle East too, but these may have been moderated after he married a Jewish wife. These problems arose in smaller matters too; according to Max, Dame Shirley Porter was instantly a thief (no she wasn't). Similarly, a deceased schoolmaster of Max's was an evil sadist. Maybe he was, which might explain a few of Max's foibles, but was it necessary for him to put it in an obituary that brought the grieving and raving widow down on me? I thought not.

View Full Article
Brian from Dublin
November 16th, 2011
2:11 PM
Can the author clarify exactly what "false prospectuses" were submitted by Ireland to qualify for the Euro? Is he aware that it is Germany who is most insistent that countries cannot default on their debts, that every cent owed by and to banks must be payed back by Irish taxpayers? I expected much better from Mr Black on the role Germany has played in the Euro crisis, both in creating it and blocking real attempts to resolve it.

Frank P
November 13th, 2011
2:11 AM
A very interesting and enjoyable tour of Hastings past and present. A Black day for Max though? I guess the complimentary arrows will wound more deeply than the critical ones.

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.