You are here:   Eurabia > Europe's Long Road to the Mosque
 

 

Justin Vaisse is not yet a household name but this young man may go far. Of North African background, he has taught at Sciences Po in Paris and been a speechwriter for the French Minister of Defence. Currently at Washington's Brookings Institution, he is the leading French expert on — and the nemesis of — the neoconservatives. The fact that he is spending time in America may not necessarily affect his political prospects. After all, Georges Clemenceau did the same. Of late, he has discovered and given publicity to what he calls a new genre in American literature: Eurabia. Among the chief protagonists in this new genre he mentions above all Bernard Lewis, the greatest Orientalist of our time, and Bat Ye'or, who popularised the term "Eurabia" to warn against the Islamicisation of Europe. In view of the homeric struggle between the two sides — Lewis has been accused of appeasement, if not worse, by the other side — it seems somewhat far-fetched to find a common denominator for them, but Vaisse is a resourceful man. 

Among the European protagonists of the Eurabian thesis, Vaisse mentions Ayaan Hirsi Ali, who was born in Somalia and now lives in the US. I am also named, although it helps him very little that in Last Days of Europe (Thomas Dunne, 2007) I devoted several pages to my unhappiness with the very term "Eurabia" which, for a variety of reasons, I have never used and thought misleading. The great majority of Muslims in Britain are not Arab but Pakistani or Bangladeshi in origin. In Germany, the Turks greatly outnumber all other Muslims. In France, the majority is North and West African. In Belgium, Turkish and Moroccan, and so on. These are not minor, pedantic issues because traditions, culture, language and even the forms of Islam practised differ considerably in Europe. While the Arabs have tried to attain positions of leadership in the European Muslim communities, this has merely given additional impetus to tensions (and among the Arabs there is a bitter struggle between Shias and Sunnis). Arabs traditionally believe that only they are the true sons of the Prophet, giving them a feeling of superiority over other Muslims.

Vaisse has not been alone in his campaign against the prophets of Eurabia. He found several sober, level-headed and well informed experts such as Jocelyne Cesari at Harvard or Jytte Klausen, a Danish scholar at Brandeis. Dr Cesari argues that there has been in the Muslim communities a strong trend towards conservativism, but that this is not tantamount to support for terrorism. This is true and some in the West have paid insufficient attention to it. But even here a word of caution is necessary. Most of our knowledge on the mood and the political orientation of Muslim communities all over the world rests on public opinion polls, most prominently those carried out by the Pew Global Attitudes Project. How reliable, though, are these polls? To give an example: a figure of 13 per cent is usually given for those in Britain sympathising with al-Qaeda. But can it be taken for granted that those asked will reveal to strangers (who, for all they know, may be agents of the security forces) the secrets of their hearts and minds? The answer seems obvious. 

To return to Vaisse's fellow experts: Professor Klausen is a happy soul. The author of Islamic Challenge (OUP, 2005), she reached the conclusion that there was no such challenge. She had interviewed some 300 professional Muslim men and women in various European countries, all middle- or upper-class businessmen, professors, lawyers and physicians, all of them reasonably content with their life and circumstances, identifying with their new countries and eager to collaborate in their social, political and economic life. There are indeed such people: the emerging Muslim elite. But the fact that these contented people are only so far a happy few seems not to have occurred to Professor Klausen. What influence do they have in their respective communities? Do the young people listen to them or to the imams? To what extent do they still identify with their erstwhile community? In Europe, most of them have moved out of Muslim ghettoes. This is not the case in India, where the Muslim middle- and upper-classes prefer to live with their coreligionists. 

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
steen wied
July 22nd, 2010
10:07 PM
Just a minor issue, sir: "Professor Klausen is a happy soul" One can put it that way. Seen here form Denmark, she is a hypocrite, if you will paron my french. I have collected quotations from her here from 2006 until her book on the Cartoons came in 2009: (some is unfortunately in danish) http://snaphanen.dk/2009/09/10/verden-bev%C3%A6ger-sig/ She did not at the time (2006) understand the wider issues at stake. She sahmed Denmark and the paper Jyllands Posten. I remeber Irshad Manji lecturing her on TV, she was so utterly ignorant, that I think we all felt sorry for her. But nowadays he poses as if her standponit in 2010 on the cartoons, is the one she has had all the time. This is not so. But ok, thats all for Jytte Klausen, the happy soul. all the best from Copenhagen, Denmark

Robert Haymond
July 2nd, 2010
5:07 PM
I came to this article via Barry Rubin's reference in his blogsite today. Walter Laqueur is, indeed, a firstrate intellectual and scholar whom I've always been impressed by although not always in agreement with, i.e., his thesis that the American Jewish leaders simply did not know about the plight of Jews in WWII and simply could not comprehend it based on the rumours which came through. We have discovered, since then, that knowledge about the plight of European Jews was known but that Jewish leaders failed to acknowledge or act on this knowledge. But Mr. Laqueur wrote on the subject before it was common knowledge that the plight of European Jews was known in the USA so he did not have the facts at hand. Having said this, I acknowledge his superior scholarship and I am grateful for his essay on the subject of Muslim integration in Europe. Unlike many, he views the whole picture in details and does not make easy generalizations.

Sarat Kumar
July 2nd, 2010
10:07 AM
Great to hear from Mr. Walter Laquer, I'm 57 but have been reading him for 40 years now. Aijaz Zaka Sayed is not Saudi but Indian ( I think he is a very poor and biased scholar.In any case,nobody in India knows about him, he only writes in Arab papers). I would like Mr Laquer to write something about India.I think he still remembers the Cold War days when India was pro-Soviet and anti-Israel but things have changed now. For all it's faults what Gandhi and Nehru created is today one of the better societies or probably the best in what was called the the third world.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.