You are here:   Columns >  European Eye > Dublin's Disappointment


Let's get it out of the way: yes, the idea of a united Europe has suffered a lot recently. 

The rerun of the Irish referendum, like the referenda in France, Denmark and Holland, failed to transmit an image of nations working together happily to create a powerful Über-state based on shared interests and values. Rather, it seemed as if a hollow, perhaps even dated concept of unity was getting the better of them, a Kafkaesque bureaucratic monster from Brussels was
forcing them to join in and swallow their concerns. So far, so bad — but the real question is: who is the culprit? 

The oddity of this moment in European history was obvious when I arrived in Ireland on the day of the vote. The streets of Dublin were plastered with simplistic slogans from both sides, happily proposing opposite actions for the same reason: "Vote yes if you wish to keep your jobs." Or: "Vote no if you wish to keep your jobs." 

This was to be a desperate referendum about the economic crisis. It had little to do with whether or not Ireland wanted to take up "its rightful place at the heart of Europe" (as various editorials claimed  —a strange wish for an island so far from the Continent). Still less was the vote about the stated purpose of the Lisbon Treaty, "to enhance the efficiency and democratic legitimacy of the European Union and to improve its coherence". 

In the end, the result showed that Ireland didn't want to become another Iceland. 

But the peculiar character of this referendum became even more palpable after the vote. When the votes had been counted, the Taoiseach, Brian Cowen, appeared before assembled journalists, two thirds of them from abroad. He posed next to the Irish tricolour, while his wife stood next to him and was almost entirely covered by the European Union flag, vigorously fluttering in the brisk autumn wind. I couldn't help feeling that I had entered a simulated parallel universe.

When Cowen spoke of "a resounding Yes" and said that the people of Ireland wished to join Europe "to work together on our future and the future of our children", he spoke as if this had been a deeply felt ideological decision that would bring overwhelming socio-political change to his country. 

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.