You are here:   Counterpoints > Heavenly Bodies

His sweetness was sympathy: “The Charity of St Thomas of Villanueva” (c.1670) by Bartolomé Esteban Murillo 

The recent Murillo exhibitions at the Dulwich Picture Gallery and the Wallace Collection prompted critics to coo, “Not as kitsch as we thought.” Perhaps they never had thought. Many of the exhibited paintings usually hang in London museums, but it has taken dedicated exhibitions to make people look at them.

Yet only 200 years ago this “Apelles of Seville” commanded the highest prices. It is more than fashion from which Murillo has fallen; it is taste.

Since that peak in Murillo’s fame, we have raised up the reputations of Brueghel, Caravaggio, Velázquez and Vermeer — all special painters, but all of them, in their different ways, realists. By Aristotle’s distinction, they would have been painters of things as they are, not of things as they seem, or ought, to be. Velázquez declared he would “rather be the first painter of common things than second in higher art”. The modern view, secular and scientific, has so craved this factual art of “common things” that the “higher” art — made of refined visions, not raw observations — is almost lost to our senses. Indeed, now that we prefer our art saltier, more realistic, even Raphael, prince of painters, is not revered as he was. Few critics may dare to call Raphael “kitsch”, but I suspect some have thought it.

So no wonder that Murillo’s reputation has suffered. But look first at Joseph and his Brethren, from the Wallace Collection, because here Murillo was at his sharpest. The composition is toughly reasoned. Follow the brothers’ gazes to discover an affective psychology. Then look at The Charity of St Thomas of Villanueva, from the same collection. The saint is a serious man, carefully solemn in his duty. A ragged beggar-boy holds up his coin; his mother’s wistful reserve is wisely painted, so that she becomes the very embodiment of dignity in poverty.

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.