You are here:   Arnaud Hauchard > La Perfide France
 

The Entente cordiale is a fine thing, but in the field of sport France and England should never give quarter. Cheating, however, is quite another thing, and that is what seems to have happened in the match between the two nations in the most recent Chess Olympiad.

To be precise, the 20-year-old French Grandmaster Sébastien Feller has been found guilty by his own national federation of using a computer to defeat England's David Howell, another precociously talented 20-year-old. It was a crucial game for the match's outcome: France had been losing  and it was only as a result of Feller's victory that the encounter ended all square. At the time — this was last September in the Siberian city of Khanty-Mansiysk — the English team thought nothing of it, except feeling disappointment at failing to win. Only later did the full extraordinary story emerge.

The vice-president of the French chess federation, Joanna Pomian, had been paying for a mobile phone for one of her team, Cyril Marzolo. This gave her access to the contents of all Marzolo's text messages. To her consternation, she discovered that there had been a very large number of texts to the French team captain, Grandmaster Arnaud Hauchard, suggesting the moves Feller should play at every stage of his game against Howell. Transmitted while the game was in progress, these moves were all the top choices given by the very strong chess computer program, Firebird, used by the French team. They were also the moves played by Feller over the board.

It seems that after Marzolo texted the suggested moves to Hauchard, who was inside the playing hall, Hauchard was able by a signing method to communicate the computer's suggestions to Feller. The text message which convinced Mme Pomian of the true purpose was one she actually saw on Marzolo's phone during the game: from Hauchard, it read "Hurry up, send moves..." By January Hauchard had confessed his role to his team mate, the top French grandmaster Maxime Vachier-Lagrave, who, together with a number of his colleagues, urged the French Chess Federation to launch a formal investigation, and act on the findings.

One can see why: this was a team event, in which the honour of the nation was at stake. More to the point as far as the players were concerned, if the now widely known circumstances were not properly dealt with by the French authorities, suspicion may have fallen upon other French grandmasters as being in some way implicated.

In March the French Chess Federation duly held a judicial session, which found that Feller, Hauchard and Marzolo were "guilty of a violation of sporting ethics" and that there was "enough proof that the three players cheated during the Olympiad". Text messages during two of Feller's other games were also considered. Marzolo was given a five-year ban from the game; Hauchard (who absented himself from the proceedings on grounds of ill-health) was given a lifetime ban from the captaincy of the French team. Feller received a three-year ban. The federation added that it had "taken into consideration the age of Sébastien Feller — he was 19 during the Olympiad".

Feller's lawyers said that the French Chess Federation had no jurisdiction over an event which had taken place in Siberia, while Hauchard's attorneys protested that the text messages between him and Marzolo were not admissible evidence, being protected by laws governing secrecy in private correspondence. These might seem technical rather than substantive defences; but legally speaking the matter is by no means concluded. Nevertheless, the chess world seems convinced that a great infamy has been detected and that it must now act to ensure that nothing of the like occurs again. 

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.