You are here:   Civilisation >  Books > Shame On All Of You
 

Jon Ronson: Courageously honest

Social media has brought about a “renaissance of public shaming”, which by and large is a healthy development: it means “the democratisation of justice”. So Jon Ronson used to think until he started coming across stories like Justine Sacco’s. Sacco was the New York PR executive who in 2013 tweeted a clumsy joke: “Going to Africa. Hope I don’t get AIDS. Just kidding. I’m white!” The tweet—actually meant to satirise Western complacency—went viral, with thousands denouncing her supposed “racist ignorance” and delighting in the sacking they were helping to make inevitable. “We are about to watch this @JustineSacco bitch get fired,” one tweeter rejoiced. “In REAL time.”

Sacco did indeed lose her job, along with her reputation and her sense of self: “I can’t fully grasp the misconception that’s happening around the world,” she tells Ronson in this timely study of public humiliation. The subject suits Ronson: he has a gift for sitting down with people, clearing away prejudices and assumptions, and letting them emerge in their humanity and complexity. And his patience gets a reward. You might expect that anyone speaking to Jon Ronson would keep their guard up, but you would be wrong. The human rights lawyer Clive Stafford Smith eagerly gives away the secret of demolishing an expert witness: bring up an obscure subject, however irrelevant, on which the expert feels “incapable of saying they don’t know. So they’ll gradually walk down the garden to the place where they look really stupid.” A man whose visits to a prostitute were exposed describes the shattering moment when they shared a laugh together: “she became human to me then. She was no longer an object. And that was the puncturing of the fantasy. It was anything I could do to get out of there.”

In many ways, this is a book about dehumanisation, a necessary part of hurting a complete stranger. Like the rest of Ronson’s work, it is full of implausible true stories told with real narrative skill and a kind of shambling charm, as though the author is unsure he is entitled to ramp up so much dramatic tension. The drawback is that he leaps from anecdote to anecdote without much of a theoretical map. The book might have benefited from a glance or two at anthropology—at, say, René Girard’s influential theory of the scapegoat. Girard argues that envy steals into human relations and builds up over time, until a group arbitrarily chooses some sacrificial object on which to pour out its anger. Ronson’s book prompts the possible conclusion that while our ancestors responded to the pressure by slaughtering animals, a more rational and enlightened age deals with it by eviscerating PR executives. As Sacco says: “I’m really suffering . . . Everybody else was very happy about that.”

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.